In light of all that has been coming to light and after the January 12 BOS meeting I have to question what currently is motivating and driving the BOS regarding the whole Glenn Marshall/investor mess relating to the Resort project.
There was a December 22 opinion letter from Mr. Whittlesey that seemed to be quite clear that a discussion should be had specifically relating to the IGA and its terms. Attorney Whittlesey, on December 22, 2008--to whom we paid more than $200,000 for his expert legal advice--stated, in an opinion letter (which Ms. Duphily demanded from me before she would even consider (then ignore) my position on this issue):
"Dear Mr. Bond:
This letter responds to your inquiry concerning the referenced agreement and the Town's situation in light of recent publicity about former tribal Chairman Glenn Marshall. Specifically, you have requested my opinion as to the Town's situation and whether there should be meetings--formal or informal--with the Tribe about the IGA.
It is my opinion that the Town's Board of Selectmen should appoint a delegation to meet and confer with the Tribe about this situation.
The allegations to which former Chairman Marshall is pleading guilty are serious and raise questions about the fundamental representations made by the tribal representatives attendant to the process through which the referenced IGA was developed. For this reason, it is my STRONG recommendation that the Town informally request meetings to discuss the specific agreements made and the foundations upon which they were determined. If the Tribe prefers to not meet under these conditions, then it would be appropriate for the Town to formally invoke the Dispute Resolution provisions of the IGA. However, I do not believe that this should be necessary."
To date, the BOS has squandered this advice and, as of January 12, actually struck any reference to the IGA from the letter requesting a meeting. This was done on a motion by Steve Spataro (up for re-election this term and supported by Casino Friends in both the last election and to avoid recall) and seconded by Ms. Duphily (also supported by Casino Friends for election)--they simply believed that the language referring to the IGA was too aggressive and didn't like the tone.
Mr. Frawley stood and politely (I note politely because some have falsely claimed he was rude)questioned:"Are we just going to ignore what has happened on the Tribal side, or are we going to deal with it?" He got no answer from the BOS, and any reference to the IGA was stricken from the letter by a 3-1 vote. Essentially, we are burying the Town's interests by being so "polite" and accommodating for fear that the investors will take the deal away. This is the time to be business aggressive in the protection of the Town's interests.
I also overheard a discussion after the meeting where Ms. Duphily was arguing with Mr. Renfrew that you cannot blame a whole Tribe for the acts of one man, any more than you can blame a whole BOS for the acts of one Selectman. Once again, this is not about the emotional blame game.
We should all consider that the Bingham's attorneys are going after an agreement with the Town of Mashpee based on the same alleged acts of fraud. They want to annul an agreement based on the alleged improprieties of Shawn Hendricks who brokered the deal with Mashpee. Why is their position any different than ours (and I believe ours may be better).
Glenn Mashall, and apparently others with him, acted in a manner that may have breached the IGA. This does not put "blame" on the whole Tribe, it simply creates a basis for a claim that is founded on the fact that he was acting in his representative capacity (as CEO of the Tribe), and that in that capacity, he may have committed an actionable wrong against the Town on the Tribe's behalf. So the BOS should be focused on fixing the problem--quickly.
All of this leaves me questioning motivations and preparation. It seems clear to me that discussion is cheap and that at the center of the storm is any impact on the IGA. The so called elephant in the bedroom. On January 12, it seems that Ms. Duphily and Mr. Spataro wanted to simply dismiss the elephant in the bedroom and try to proceed like nothing is wrong. I beg to differ, and I do so a just one man, and a citizen of Middleboro, and in a manner similar to Amelia Bingham and her lawyers.
Apropos of this issue, I was asked about the two occasions I previously referenced where an elected official spoke to the Tribe or its agents about information that I believe was damaging to the interests of the Town by being disclosed. It seems like a fair request, and it is a request that I can answer from personal knowledge.
When I took action after the Tribe, through its then Chairman, Shawn Hendricks, excluded us from their request to the Governor to have compact negotiations, I acted as quickly as I could to preserve our right to be at the compact negotiations--as promised by the negotiators. Acting alone, since nobody else had yet identified the gravity of the situation, I wrote a blog that accomplished the purpose of having the Tribe retract the letter and include us in the request for compact negotiations.
Mimi Duphily, who, as she put it, wanted to "rip my face off" because she had to deal with calls from reporters and people coming into her shop (I deal with this regularly), was visited by Helen Belmont, President of Middleboro Friends/Member of Casino Friends. According to what both Mimi and Helen told me (and argued about with me at a later meeting), Mimi and Helen spoke, and then Helen called Steve Graham on her cell phone and put Mimi on the phone to talk with Steve Graham. Steve Graham is one of the Tribe's negotiators for the IGA and also serves as their political consultant/handler.
Mimi let Steve Graham know that I acted alone and that the rest of the BOS knew nothing about it, and by doing so disclosed that the BOS was divided and easily assailable. I still am dumbfounded that, she called the other side...not her own Board Member to find out what was going on. She felt more comfortable contacting the Tribe and its political handler, rather than calling a member of her own Town Board. She told me that she didn't call me because she was so mad at me, and because she knew I was going out of Town. Last I looked, the cell phones work all over the country, and I spoke to Town hall at least three times that day, and the Tribe was able to get me to discuss the matter while I was boarding a plane to Tennessee. Mimi then took three days to return my call to her (because she was so mad), which I made after I found out she wanted to rip my face off.
The second incident was when Aaron Tobey, a tribal council member, contacted me for a man to man discussion about the Marshall indictment issues. Aaron and I spoke on condition that we both agreed neither spoke for his group and that nothing we said would in any way bind either side. I had our TM immediately send an e-mail to all the Selectmen to let them know that I would be meeting with him--because I did not want Mimi to be so mad that she would want to rip my face off, and I had promised my board that I would keep them in the loop in the future. The agenda and results of the meeting immediately were discussed with the TM. Apparently, Mimi,contacted someone at the Tribe to find out who this Aaron Tobey was that was meeting with Adam Bond, which set off a fire storm at the Tribal end that could have broken down any possibility of fruitful discussion. How did she know which council members are involved in improprieties, and why didn't she just call me (or the TM) to ask who he was--I was in Town, told her about it through e-mail, and she should not have been mad at me. Apparently, she just feels more comfortable with the Tribe and their interests than any discussions with me. But Aaron was a gentleman about it all--upset, but a gentleman.
Again, I am concerned that the Town's interests and/or strategies are being overlooked (and leaked)for some esoteric and emotional reason relating to how certain individuals feel about the tribal members on a personal level. If you want to love the Tribe, feel free, but as an elected official it is the deal that needs to be harnessed and dealt with professionally for the interest of the Town.
However, to the Town's detriment, this Board has telegraphed in no uncertain terms and loudly that it will never walk away from this deal under any circumstances and regardless of the consequences, because it NEEDS this casino. Apparently, the BOS will take everything that is thrown at it and continue to defend the Tribe at every turn. This is no way to handle a contract or deal of this magnitude. There is absolutely no reason that the Tribe or the investors will ever enter productive discussions with this backdrop of unqualified acceptance by the Town arising out of a sense of utter desperation or NEED.
From my perspective, I am for the deal and resolving these issues promptly--which includes all the promises that were made and the expectations formed along with its creation and vote. If I believe my Town's interests are damaged by the actions of the other side, I would take any and all steps to get those issues resolved, all the way to the remedy of parting ways (which is always and is still a viable option). My Town's interests (as I see them) are paramount, and a willingness to walk away is as important to the Town as a willingness to stay and work it out. They don't own us...yet...or do they?
But this is just my opinion as an individual citizen and just one of five Selectmen.
Wednesday, January 21, 2009
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
Great job Adam. Candid...nice piece. Stay classy Middleboro, no casino for your children’s sake. The Bingham’s are a classy bunch. This whole deal has been a breach of confidence since the beginning. Country bumpkins being taken advantage of along with a delusional town vote have led us to the doorstep of polluting a beautiful rural town on the fringe. Adam is a noble man for stepping up in the face of adversity. There is no other choice but to protect our interests. Even Middleboro locals who are blissful and totally smitten, overwhelmed by their own pride and personal ties to the issue, still make themselves believe a "casino" is good in their town at all costs. That’s emotions, sort of like what Adam is referring too. Too much irony and too many lies and corruption. Wayne Perkins, former BOS member at the initial negotiations, once said in the beginning..."there was once 20,000 Wampanoag living in Middleboro, this is there home"...well Wayne, no, your wrong, there was only a total of 15,000 living in the entire state of Massachusetts at the highest point. Maybe a 1000 in the ‘boro, maybe, either way you are way off…but the Middleboro people still believe you. There have been too many rash decisions and false perceptions of monetary gains. The streets of Middleboro, as fantastic as a casino sounds, need a casino as much as Obama needs issues to deal with. Seriously, IGA representational and fiscal failure, projected town service costs, environmental and water impact, traffic and population increase assessments...all point to negative. What is good about those things??? This is not rocket science. That is all negative. It's okay. After all, we don't want it. A casino is not the answer. It isn't. Too many indicators. Lets all take a step back, take three deep breaths and repeat, "my life is good the way it is". See? Middleboro doesn't need a casino! Maybe a couple of overrides but not a casino.
I ascertain from your post that Stephen Graham is pulling the strings for the Tribe, Casino-Friends, AND at least two Middleboro selectmen.
We have the IGA in place which is an agreement to build a huge monstrosity of a resort casino in an essentially residential area of town. The IGA is NOT an agreement to turn political control of the Town over to the Tribe OR Casino-Friends, OR Stephen Graham.
Ms. Duphily and Mr. Spataro, as well as all the selectmen need to understand who elected them. They represent the citizens of Middleboro, and Middleboro alone. Failure to act in the best interests of Middleboro consitutes a conflict of interest and is a serious breach of ethics and public trust.
In Town Meeting of July 28, 2007, casino supporters voted yes "for Middleboro's future". Well, the future is now and what do we have?
1) Ineffective selectman sitting on the BOS.
2) Infighting among our selectman.
3) A Tribe and a Town being controlled by lobbyists and casino investors.
4) A Town that remains divided over this issue that should never have happened in the first place.
5) A town run ambulance service that, oh wait, that's a pipe dream NOW that the BOS realize it's cost prohibitive.
6) An agreement that, as it's now coming to light, is inadequate in it's guarantees and promises of good faith for the Town of Middleboro.
The IGA has brought us nothing, NOTHING, but headaches and division. I was a happier Middleboro resident prior to July 28, 2007. Now? Well, let's just say I have one thing in common with Mimi Duphily, I too want to rip someone's face off.
I'd also like to add, if Mimi Duphily is so objectionable to receiving phone calls from reporters and being questioned by town residents, maybe she doesn't have the stomach for public service. Why did she want to be a selectman in the first place? Was it solely to secure a friendly seat on the BOS for the Tribe, Casino-friends, and Stephen Graham?
It is said a fish rots from the head down. If Glenn Marshall is the head of the IGA, then certainly the Middleboro BOS are the gills. There is a malodorous scent coming off the IGA right now. Usually when something begins to rot this way, it is an indication that it is dead. We need to separate ourselves from the political corruption that comes with being in bed with casino investors. Just imagine, right now all we have is an "agreement" for a casino. How bad will it get and how much will our Town change for the worse when and if we have an actual casino?
No amount of money will repair the damage a casino and it's problems will do to Middleboough. Just look at the damage it has already done. When are you going to realize a casino will be bad for Middleborough? It's time to put and end to it, before it's too late.
If you believe what you have written, it is up to you to contact the proper authorities and help with the investigation.
You will have my support and the support of many in Middleboro if you do the right thing.
Adam, Adam how could you abandon us? Look who you have left us with for our BOS. Rogers couldn't wait to adjust your chair height, Marsha was Vice but really ran the meeting, Mimi, of course, was drooling with delight, and Steve didn't speak again for a long while. Please tell me you have a master plan. btw trust only Victoria,Avery and yourself and get an enclosed office with a door. bj
Post a Comment